Charles Barton's Big Idea that only an Advocate Could Truly "Get"

Charles Barton is among only a handful of Bloggers that regularly blog and enlighten the nuclear energy advocates and the rest of the lay persons who are fortunate enough to find their postings.

His Big Lots Reactor Revisited and his original article over a year ago

What’s behind this idea is that the Thorium Molten Salt Reactor can go in numerous directions and has many applications.

The fact that the LFTR design is not written in stone allows for speculation and Charles makes an important point about how Thorium Molten Salt Reactor designs amazing potential to produce energy can be downsized in a way that would extend the life of the reactor itself and provide a way to launch a fourth generation reactor much sooner by using existing materials which is partly inspired by David Leblanc’s design.

Just when so many people in high places are saying generation IV is not reachable for 10 or 20 years Charles Barton suggests we could start this much sooner. And unlike a lot of the Nuclear Energy advocates who see the energy solution as mostly nuclear this idea introduces how the Big Lots Reactor concept would work in tandem with other renewable energy providers such as wind and solar or as what’s called “load following” which up till Charles came along was depending on Natural Gas as the leading fuel replacement when the we have no windy days.

David LeBlanc on Travelling Wave Reactor (TWR)

The idea has some merit but is basically a huge sodium cooled fast breeder where power production starts at one end and travels across to the other. They expect the fuel elements to last 60 years in core, how on earth do you expect to trust a solid fuel element that long? As well, while it can start with somewhat less fissile material than a traditional fast breeder but will end up with massive amounts (10s of tons) in the core at the end of life. Just like all fast breeder folks they try to make it sound like being able to use depleted uranium as fuel will somehow drive the price of electricity down, it won`t, capital costs are everything and I`d be hard pressed to imagine a more costly design.

They have to be taken seriously though as they`ve hired up some of the absolute best minds in the nuclear industry to work on this. My hope is this will spur some of the other mega-rich to help fund the far more promising field of molten salt reactors.

David LeBlanc